Supporters of the “Not Dead Yet” campaign, which opposes the Assisted Dying Bill, react outside the Houses of Parliament as news breaks that the Bill has passed the first stage, on November 29, 2024 in London, England.
| Photo Credit: Getty Images
British lawmakers gave initial approval on Friday (November 29, 2024) to a bill to help terminally ill adults end their lives in England and Wales, following an impassioned debate that saw people sharing personal stories of loss and suffering.
Members of Parliament approved the assisted dying bill by a 330-275 vote, signalling their approval in principle for the bill, which will undergo further scrutiny before it goes to a final vote.
Friday’s vote came after hours of debate — emotional at times — that touched on issues of ethics, faith and law. There was no braying and shouting that often marks debates in the House of Commons and speeches were considered respectfully and heard in silence.
“Let’s be clear, we’re not talking about a choice between life or death, we are talking about giving dying people a choice about how to die,” the bill’s main sponsor, Kim Leadbeater, said as she presented the bill to a packed chamber.
Supporters said the law would provide dignity to the dying and prevent suffering, while protecting the vulnerable.
Opponents said the disabled and elderly were at risk of being coerced, directly or indirectly, to end their lives to save money or relieve the burden on family members. Others called for the improvement of palliative care to ease suffering as an alternative.
Labour MP Kim Leadbeater, who proposed the landmark private member’s bill on assisted dying, meets campaigners after a parliamentary vote was passed in support of assisted dying on November 29, 2024 in London, England.
| Photo Credit:
Getty Images
The proposed bill would allow adults over the age of 18 who are expected to have fewer than six months to live to request and be provided help to end their life, subject to several safeguards.
They would have to be capable of taking the fatal drugs themselves, and two independent doctors and a High Court judge will have to sign off on any decision. The bill will not apply to Scotland or Northern Ireland.
Arguments for and against
Backers of the bill told heart-wrenching stories about constituents and family members who suffered in the final months of their lives and dying people who committed suicide in secret because it is currently a crime for anyone to provide assistance.
Danny Kruger, who led the argument against the bill, cautioned lawmakers not to back a “state suicide service.” He argued that no amount of safeguards will stop many vulnerable people feeling the pressure to make a request to end their lives.
Mr. Kruger voiced his disappointment at the outcome but said there’s a chance lawmakers will reject the bill when it comes back for a vote in the next few months. Some of those voting in favor said they only did so to examine the details further and could potentially vote against it in the future.
“I still think we can stop it,” he said.
Across the political divide
Although the bill was proposed by Ms. Leadbeater, a member of the ruling center-left Labour Party, it was an open vote with alliances formed across the political divide.
The government is widely expected to come up in the next few months with assessments on how assisted dying will be funded and how it would impact the U.K.’s state-funded National Health Service, hospice care and the legal system.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer did not show his hand ahead of the vote, but backed the change. Others in his Cabinet, including Health Secretary Wes Streeting and the Justice Minister Shabana Mahmood, voted against. There were similar divisions across other political parties.
Long-time British campaigner Esther Rantzen, who is terminally ill with lung cancer and played a leading role in advocating the need for a vote on assisted dying, voiced her joy at the “wonderful” outcome and said it will give people an “equal choice.”
When diagnosed with her terminal illness, Ms. Rantzen said she would travel to Switzerland to bring an end to her life, where the law allows assisted dying for non-residents.
Hundreds of people on both sides of the issue gathered outside Parliament on a cold but bright day as the debate continued for nearly five hours.
Opponents held signs saying, “Kill the bill, not the ill,” and, referring to the National Health Service, “NHS It’s cradle to grave. Not ’til old, inconvenient or expensive!”
The group Dignity in Dying, many wearing pink winter hats, led supporters as they clutched signs saying “Giving me choice over my death,” and “You can’t cure death. Please make it fear free.”
Backers of the measure erupted in cheers when the result was announced and hugged each other.
“It’s a relief, it’s history, finally we are getting towards having a society that shows love and compassion above the need to just keep people alive,” said Joshua Cook, 33, who has Huntington’s disease, an incurable neurodegenerative disease.
Other countries that have legalised assisted suicide include Australia, Belgium, Canada and parts of the United States, with regulations on who is eligible varying by jurisdiction.
Assisted suicide is different from euthanasia, allowed in the Netherlands and Canada, which involves health care practitioners administering a lethal injection at the patient’s request in specific circumstances.
Published – November 30, 2024 01:30 pm IST
